The material presented
here is not Al-Anon Conference Approved Literature. It is a method
to exchange
information, ideas, feelings, problems and solutions on a personal
level.
Okay so this is getting a little on the personal side and I apologize in advance if I offend anyone...
Is it unreasonable of me to refuse sex to my A when he is drunk? He is acting like I'm the most unreasonable callous person on the planet and I just tried to nicely explain that I'm not interested in intimacy with the drunk version of him...Or since I did commit to him, perhaps I really am supposed to just get through it to keep him happy - drunk or not? The thing is, this is a bigger issue to me than just attraction. While I've done a lot of healing regarding ongoing sexual abuse as a kid, the fact is I still get a little messed up when I don't think someone is allowing me to say no as an adult...It does serious damage to my self esteem and also to how I feel about him. I've tried to explain this but when he's drunk it just doesn't matter... Now I will likely get the silent treatment until tomorrow night or the next day! Sometimes I think this would all be easier if I just joined him and got drunk, too!
Personal and confusing ...again hope I'm not getting into forbidden territory...
It took me along time to understand that I had a right to say NO .. for all the reasons u just stated .. I asked my husb whn reasonably sober that if he could not come to our bed smelling of soap and toothpaste to please not touch me , luckily for me , my husb was a gentleman he apologized and did try to do as I asked but he didnt try to force the issue . I can only relate to sexual abuse by what I allowed .. anyone who has slept with a wet drunk understands abuse .. Oh and there is not much that cannot be discussed on this board . Intamcy is not discussed often enough and it is a major problem in our circumstances .. Getting drunk will only add to your confusion , u deserve to treat yourself better. * hugs*
This is a very important issue you are raising here, and one which I personally have struggled greatly with, you are absolutely entitled to set boundaries and be shown respect, I have felt threatened many times and have been intimidated into submission, sex is not a weapon to be used as a form of intimidation, I applaud your strength and thank you for raising this ugly side of ism!
Lovealwayshopes, this is an important issue and Im glad you asked the question.
I dont have a direct answer, because there is none. It depends on what you will and will not allow. I got married to the A in 1984 and in 1993, I stopped having sex with him. We separated and I filed for divorce 18 months ago. That gives you an idea of how long I havent had sex. Except for a little flirtation I had with another person around 2004, but I didnt have sex with this other person.
It really has to be totally your decision. I found it not to be pleasant anymore, as you already know. My x ah, was out a lot of nites, hardly came home, many times, so I didnt know for sure if there were other women, so with it being an unpleasant experience and the possibility of other women, I stopped having sex.
There can be consequences that you should be aware of. If he wasnt having sex with other woman at the time I stopped, he certainly did afterward. I found out in 2004, that he was having an affair since 1994. Off and on again, and that she gave birth to twins in 2004. The A had a heart attack shortly after that, I nursed him thru that year and found out at the end that she had given birth to twins. A girl and a boy. They were a year old when I found out. It wasso crazy, the A was drinking a lot of vodka. The Police found him passed out in the middle of a busy hiway, he fell out of his truck, but someone beat him up and fractured his ribs. That was a time I separated from the A. He wanted nothing to do with her or the kids. He was insane and out of control. I do have to add that, my x ah was telling me how difficult it was to have sex also, that he couldn't do it because of the drinking .
Lovealwayshopes, I know I never caused his drinking, but I will never know if I drove him into the arms of another woman. Would I do it again. Perhaps I should of approached him more on the subject and made it somewhat of a priority, but there was so much to deal with in those 26 years of marriage. I hope I have given you more insight and have not discouraged you. Just giving you my honest experience on this subject. Not sure if it will help. Wishing you strength , courage and wisdom, Bettina
-- Edited by Bettina on Thursday 1st of April 2010 02:48:00 AM
abbyal is right on the money. "No" is a complete sentance. I enjoy having an active healthy sex life w/my A bf of the last 15 yrs of whom we share a teen daughter. I really had to look at my motives on this... many times i used sex/intimacy as a weapon or bargaining chip by withholding it or doling it out as 'rewards', a sick twisted game of manipulation on my part which was hit/miss at best. Yet when i really took an honest look at my part (the things i CAN change) I too chose to talk to him at a reasonably soberish time about my total turn offs... like reeking feet, BO, nasty breath, dirty hands, greasy grimy clothing etc etc you know the drill... I also dont care to sleep w/a sloppy wet drunk... but when ya live w/active alcoholism thats what ya tend to get, due to the schedules we keep (i work evenings, i'm a nite owl... he keeps day hrs and is usually sloppy or passed out by the time i get home) So i dont do the 'nighttime rondevous' usually... i'm more of a 'chop the morning wood' kinda girl ;) Perhaps you can find a happy medium/some kind of balance for yourself too. Alanon puts out a great book on this very topic by the way... its title is "The Dilemma of the Alcoholic Marriage". Well worth the read.
Yes it is unreasonable to the drunk and Yay anyway. If it didn't feel like being loved I wasn't up for it...hmmmm how could I ever be up for it. A body was there but she wasn't...no mind, no spirit, no companionship. It was just F'ing and how empty is that when you're all alone with the drunk there but not there. Calling sex love was/is a poor justification and an attempt at a guilt trip or something worse when I say no to it, to her and to me.
Be unreasonable to the drunk and save your self esteem and self worth.
Alanon teaches me to focus on myself. If I am uncomfortable with anything in my life I am learning to say NO and develop my own self esteem. I had to learn that marriage does not make me my husbands property to do with as he pleases. Drunk or sober, if I chose not to give away that part of me that is so intimate then my husband has to deal with it. Its his issue then not mine. Abuse is abuse, mentally, physically or emotionally.
Obviously I have to be careful not to use intimacy as a weapon and be honest about my reasons. It would be very wrong to use sex as a form of control or manipulation, but protection of who I am as a person is good for me and very appropriate I think Mon
I agree w the other posters. This is a personal boundary issue and a personal intimacy issue with YOUrself first. Since u sd u did suffer sex abuse -- your inner child/inner abused person wants you to stand up for her, to protect her. Its about self respect first and foremost. As an adult, you can say "No".
A drunk person wont understand anything you're saying.
This is about loving, valuing and respecting YOU first. You deserve your own best love. You are worth the boundaries you set - respect, value & honor yourself.
-- Edited by kitty on Thursday 1st of April 2010 01:59:18 PM
-- Edited by kitty on Thursday 1st of April 2010 02:00:54 PM
__________________
Light, Love, Peace, Blessings & Healing to Us All. God's Will Be Done. Amen.
I'd say the test of unreasonableness is how you feel about it, not whether he feels it's unreasonable. It's your boundary.
Drunk sex was an easy one for me, because an intoxicated man is thoroughly repulsive to me. There was no question of refusing intimacy to manipulate because I had NO desire to be physically close to a drunk. Both of my XABFs were in recovery so when they relapsed they went from sober to blotto pretty quickly, and beyond the point where sex was even possible (although they did try!).
I set out that boundary firmly and unmistakeably right away after the first relapse: I will not have sex with you when you're drunk. Some little kernel of memory of that would remain when they relapsed, because all they needed was one reminder and they would stop trying.
__________________
Finish each day and be done with it. You have done what you could... Tomorrow is a new day. You shall begin it serenely and with too high a spirit to be encumbered with your old nonsense. - Emerson
I've tried to explain this but when he's drunk it just doesn't matter... Now I will likely get the silent treatment until tomorrow night or the next day! Sometimes I think this would all be easier if I just joined him and got drunk, too!
Dear Love Always Hopes
I agree with everything that has been posted to your question I would just like to add that my husband tried to use the "Not talking" routine with me as well. I discovered his not talking to me was wonderful!!! I could focus on myself, do my thing, pray, reflect and build my own life. When he discovered that I was not adversely troubled by his "punishment" he stopped.
Please, Please donot try to drink with him I do believe that that attitude was mentioned in John's posting on how not to enable. My hubby wanted me to drink with him What could be better in an alcoholic's mind than a wife who approves, drinks with him and sex. It DOES NOT work and is much harder to extricate yourself from.
Alanon taught me how not to abandon myself and who I was for any relationship or person.
Keep ccming here focus on you and your needs , share and know that you are worth it.
I am not married to an A but have had A bf's in the past and seriously felt repulsed at the idea of sex with them while they were drunk so although I wan't in alanon at the time I set that boundary. Being inimate ( if you can call it that ) with someone who is there only in body ( not mind or spirit) seemed like a small part of me died each time. So I think if that is a boundry you are going to set good for you. I don't see it as manipulation at all
I had to put the same boundary in place with my ex-AW (yes, a man refusing sex, lol). The issue of "reasonableness" is yours, and not his, to decide. Your boundary is the same as mine was, and for you.... I found sex with a drunk to be meaningless, unfulfilling, and tough on my self-esteem.
Take care Tom
__________________
"He is either gonna drink, or he won't.... what are YOU gonna do?"
"What you think of me is none of my business"
"If you knew the answer to what you are worrying about, would it REALLY change anything?"
I also have a "no sex/no touching" policy with my AH while he is drunk. In fact, I am in the middle of renos on the spare room so I can move in there on nights he is drinking as I also cannot stand the smell of booze/smoke and the snoring that comes with it.
My issue is that I also do not feel like sex with him even when he is 'sober', as he is still a demanding/selfish person days after his drunk. I tried to explain it to him when he was sober, and stated that I just do not feel 'connected' to him lately, and as such do not feel like having sex. For me, the urge is an emotional one, and when I am not emotionally connected, I don't feel the urge. I have tried 'doing it for him' a couple of times, but it didn't feel right to me.. almost had that 'floating outside my body' feeling like I was protecting myself from being emotionally hurt...
Perhaps I need to work some more on detaching with love instead of just detaching with indifference, as I think this may be what is driving some of the 'distance' between us.. then again.. AH's demanding/selfish comments/actions could also be why that distance is there.
For now.. I focus on doing what makes me happy, and if AH can't 'make himself happy' so to speak (wink wink) and needs to go outside the marriage to satisfy himself, that's his choice. I will deal with that if that day comes.
On second thought this is such a very very important thread and I am using a second and third read and then a self inventory of myself on the subject and I don't find myself outside the group. If I focus on the alcoholic alone I only get one part of the picture and then that old question pops up again, "What is my part in it?" Dang!! There were many times when it was just about me also...It wasn't about "we" only me and my nerve endings. I have to admit that at times (often in the past before program) to me it was like using or drinking because I was only going for self affect. Yeah I know about the sex with a drunk and so did my exwife alcoholic and I know also about what an Al-Anon member once termed in a meeting "sexual gymnastics" and then the program changed all that when it inserted the concept of a Power Greater than myself and proper recovery values and how to get them like if I don't like having it done to me don't do it to others. When I got here I didn't know anything including anything on the proper behavior with sex and now that I cannot point my finger out at anyone else it's all about me being reasonable with my HP, the program, myself and others.
I wanna hear more....I want it now!! (that still feels sooo good at times.)
I've found that whenever you set a boundary with an A, they have a "push back" response. Their focus is on themselves and what they want, and when they're drunk even more so -- they're not looking at the bigger picture. And if you set a boundary they don't like, especially if it is about alcohol and its consequences (such as "I don't feel intimate when you've been drinking"), they have a really big vested interest in making it no so, in trying to pretend that nothing's wrong and that you should behave just as if they were not drunk and as if they were not AWOL in the relationship. They want to erase your reality and enforce their reality instead. But you get to own your reality, which is that you do mind. I recently read something about the importance of developing honesty in our lives, which pointed out that pretending that something's okay with us when it isn't okay is dishonest. Sometimes we're raised to be good and "go along," but that's dishonest. We can draw a boundary without being mean. (Though the A's often try to say that any boundary is mean -- that is so not true.) And saying calmly that we're not okay with it when we're not okay with it is a good honest boundary. You could even say that not drawing it is enabling -- letting the A think there are no consequences, when the consequence is that you're not attracted to a drunk.
Thinking about it some more after Jerry's post.. My part in it I mean... That's why I love this stuff. I just had an Ah Ha moment...
I think my part in this is a couple of things, the detachment with love vs detachment with indifference that I need to grow with and develop is a big one.
The other part is the fact that I have not been taking great care of myself physically (20, Ok 30 extra pounds, need a haircut/colour, haven't been shopping for new clothes/shoes in a long time, even my underwear have holes!) This is affecting my self esteem and the way I feel about my body. I have noticed when I feel good about myself and take care of myself, my sex drive goes up and all of a sudden, I can picture my self having sex and actually WANT to do it. This has happened a couple times in the past couple months when we have gone out for a 'date' together. At first I thought it was just 'connecting' and spending time together. Which I am sure is some of it, but now I realize that on those 'dates' I actually spent some time before hand on ME. Did my hair and makeup, put on clothes other than sweats. Got myself mentally in the 'mood' Maybe that was also part of the recipe for success. Thought I was doing it for him, but just realized, its for ME.
When I feel bad about myself, my AH's touch actually annoys me, as I feel like he is rubbing all my squishy bits (tummy, butt etc..) to get to me, to make me feel bad. He'll ask me to show him my 'parts' and to me it feels like a demand. I wonder if I felt good about myself whether I would LIKE to show off and perceive his request in a different way. Perhaps I am projecting my negative feelings about myself onto him and seeing him as demanding. The great news is, focusing on changing this (loving ME and taking care of ME) is one of the things I need to do anyway! And there may be some payoff in the love department for AH at the end of it...
Now.. not sure if I will ever get feeling good enough about myself to want to 'do it' when AH is actually drunk...
Off to sign up for weight watchers online now!
Thanks Jerry... for the reminder about "what's my part in it..."
It is my experience that if a husband or wife do not feel up to it, then they don't. Does not have to be their A is drunk. Could be a number of reasons.
Possibly going into detail to a person when they are drunk is pointless anyway.
If one feels they need to explain, surely do it when they are sober.
I guess a, "hon I don't fee like it" should be enough. How they respond is up to them.
One may need to be reassured of your love for them, which would be natural. But more than that for me does not matter.
you are a very caring, sensitive person. Great share. love,debilyn
__________________
Putting HP first, always <(*@*)>
"It's not so much being loved for ourselves, but more for being loved in spite of ourselves."
Missy Poo, if I didn't have my own room and bathroom, I would have never survived a marriage and Im talking about any marriage, even one that wasn't with an A, but especially because my x was an A.
It was my sanctuary!!! I would turn on the New Age music, close my eyes and wait for blue to appear. I did a lot of acupuncture which would produce this blue that would pulse. So, I learned how to create it. Its a healing color , so I hear. It sure worked for me.
It was my mini vacation. !!! Without leaving my room.!
Bettina
-- Edited by Bettina on Thursday 1st of April 2010 07:09:00 PM
It says in the 'family disease' section at the top of the page here, Some typical problems include:Guilt: family members begin to believe the alcoholic's accusations and take the blame.
I think this game playing that AH's do to get their own way is so toxic. I feared he would go else where for sex....then eventually I hoped he would and I would have a reason other than his drinking to end the marriage.
I hated how he pointed out all my flaws and his accusations. I never once thought to consider just not reacting. I knew it was all lies. He stole my self esteem and I let him because I believed him.
I tried so hard to be the dutiful wife because thats what loving wives do......make love to their husbands when ever they demand it....isn't it???? As well as cooking meals keeping the house clean, dealing with kids, driving my husband to work and back because hed lost his license again, working all hours I could around all that plus of course paying the bills, running around trying to catch my husband out lying, drinking, cheating.
I was SOOOOO relieved when someone in Alanon talked about how insane all these things were. I was under the mental health professionals crying to them I just wanted it all to stop..... Maybe they did tell me to stop reacting there I don't know. I couldn't hear anyone telling me anything. I could just stop it all just by not playing the game. But I justified every bad behaviour with a ...yes but.... and projected all my fears. My consequences affected other people and I couldn't let that happen.
Of course my AH got cross and sulked when I stopped playing his game. He got quite angry about it. He LIKED playing his game. It kept him drunk. He took no responsibility because the game told him it was all ok. I TOLD him by my actions it was all ok...
He was so shocked when he said ....as usual....that I didn't understand him and I replied ....you're right I don't and I don't have to. Its not my job.
Steps one and two were just amazing to me I have no control over anything my AH does or says, or my adult kids for that matter But I can change anything I am not comfortable with.... regardless of his reactions or the misguided teachings of my parents or church. When my life is unmanageable it is because I have lost my focus on my own needs.
I can refuse to walk on eggshells or engage in any behaviour I don't feel is good for my own wellbeing. Alanon and my Higher Power teach me constantly to consider honestly what my intentions are. Because my AH or my kids also have the same freedom to consider their own wellbeing regardless of me. Letting go of them is a loving thing to do and allows them the dygnity of living their own lives
we all learn from our consequenses, but we can only live today
I have one life to live and my Higher Power is in charge of it, not my husband. He has his own Higher Power and I'm not it...
Saying "No" about whether or not I want to share my body with anyone at anytime is never unreasonable. I live in here and need to fully approve anything that is ingested, put upon or enters it in any way. That should be every person's right no matter what. I would lose respect and trust towards anyone who questioned my ability to decide whether I wanted to share myself with them or not.
(((((Family)))))...this is a major thread; sooooo supportive of thinking and choice and changing perceptions to fit positive change. I am grateful. While I was reading a question recrossed my mind. It had before this. "What part or how much of Love, (My definition "the complete and total acceptance of all others for exactly who they are".) is sex anyway? I love open but don't desire sex from any on those I love except my wife and at times she has problems with not being on a pedestal. I love because I am able and because it feels good going out and coming back and if it doesn't come back it still feels good going out.
I know this is a wandering off from Love's original post but I like the question.
true enuff... sex is very small part of that total love concept indeed... yet can be an intregal part, for myself anyway. In my original share i used the disclaimer of "usually" when referring to midnite rondevous not happening w/ a sloppy drunk. For me personally... if he's just got a buzz or glow on, not fully lit up like a christmas tree (talkin bout his state or level of inebriation) and he just smells musky... little smoke in his hair... little alcohol on his breath... little twinkle in his eye, lil devilish grin... i'm in!! I can be persuaded and it aint all bad! But if I really wanna get totally honest, i'd also have to admit that SOMETIMES I follow thru w/submitting just cause i know he'll pass out soon after, i guess that would be my 'payoff'. And when i do say no... which is alot more often than i'd really like it to be... i do hear him mumbling as he rolls over "... mean ole b*tch..." which makes me smile and i'm really starting to think of more as a pet name instead of a derogatory thing... and it sure beats the hell outta the old "xxxx psyco b*tch!" that he USED to call me :)
i apologize for offending anyone w/my honesty,
wendy
-- Edited by canadianguy on Friday 2nd of April 2010 12:13:11 PM
I do have to add this, I forgot, we must not forget how to laugh, I know our circumstances are serious, but looking back at this scenario, I do have to laugh.
The x Ah, was always telling me for years that he could not function sexually. The time he was having the affair with the other women , was on again, but he told me he was going to AA meetings, he would come late and drunk, I told him I dont know of any AA meetings where they serve drinks.. But anyway one nite, we stopped at the store, he went in and I searched his truck, (I know, but I couldnt help myself, and it was beyond the point of no return) well in a secret compartment, I pull out this plastic bag and it is full with hundreds of little blue pills, VIAGRA!! When he walked out of the store, I threw the pills all over the parking lot. No wonder he had a heart attack before. There were enough pills to choke a horse. LOL
Betina you are a crack up! hey my AH had problems. I didn't care, I loved him and kisses and hugs are fine. BUT he stopped everything.
I thought about giving him viagra with his vitamins more than once!
What a mess eh?
Was sitting here thinking, reversies, that being an A is a disease. Ok when I had horrible pms I was awful. Then I would be back to me, very easy going, loving, always laughing.
BUT if I knew my husband did not want to be with me when I was pms'ing, it would have made me feel all the more guilty!
so again I guess I would not tell them the reason I did not want to be with him that way becuz he was using. Just makes things worse to me.
I agree with Jennifer too that it is our body, we have the right to choose with no explanation.
Everyone sure has great responses.
I could never have sex without love. It was a waste of time for me. Kept me celibet for years at a time, and here I am again....sigh.
So no sex for me with out love BUT I loved my AH so much it did not matter one bit when he couldn't or chose not to in case he couldn't. so sad, we had such a great love for so many years....love,deb
__________________
Putting HP first, always <(*@*)>
"It's not so much being loved for ourselves, but more for being loved in spite of ourselves."
I continue to read and get a bit morose as I inventory all of the sexually intimate relationships I have had and this is far from a brag because what I was looking for was love but what always seemed to be most important was the sex, the release, the climax and the end. Sex has an end and what I was looking for had none or I wanted it to have none. Know what I'm trying to say? I resent the feeling of "just being used for" as much as I have had the feeling of having "used" someone else. There is no love in it; just the attempt to fulfill a need. That is how it's been in my journey in this disease; the difference between "I love you" and "I need you". Lots of sex...very little love; Bummer!
Some people just don't care about the love aspect. I try to stay away from those today. I learned about love in the program of the Al-Anon Family Groups and it was painful higher education. Thanks ((((hugs))))
Jerry's question brought back an interesting memory of a teenage boyfriend, that I thought I loved. We of course, did what unsupervised teenagers did at the time and probably still do and ended up as close to having sex as humanly possible when I said stop and asked the strangest question. Would you rather have sex with me right now or be my best friend forever? We did not have sex, and that is when I knew he really loved me, and that I really loved him. We're still best friends, and I am pretty sure if we had gone thru with it we wouldn't be friends.
I have shared my body with someone I did not love, I have shared my love and innermost being with many people I did not have sex with and am fine with all of it. But there is something about sharing all of it together that definitely changes my expectations. This is going to take alot more thought to figure out.