Al-Anon Family Group

The material presented here is not Al-Anon Conference Approved Literature. It is a method to exchange information, ideas, feelings, problems and solutions on a personal level.

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Should I keep my son away from his father?


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:
Should I keep my son away from his father?


My partner (my 6-year-old son's father) is an alcoholic with a history of near death experiences.

 

He can go from 1-3 years sober. But when he falls off the wagon, it is always under very traumatic circumstances. After a year and a half of sobriety, I finally allowed him to move back in with us. I then trusted him enough to leave our son in his care for 3 weeks while I went to work in Paris. (That is, they were to join me in 3 weeks.) But he started drinking immediately and I had to fly back 3 days into my work and pick up my son from my neighbors (who, THANK GOD) are wonderful people and rescued my son from his out-of-it father. This was DEVASTATING for me and my son and cost me about $10k of unexpected expenses.

So....had he continued drinking, it would be very easy to say that he needs to have no contact with us (particularly my son) BUT he quit immediately after his 2-day bender and got back on track with full remorse.

It is so hard because he has SO much to offer our son except for when he falls off the wagon at these years long intervals. And WHEN he falls it is SO traumatic for me and now for my son (this is the first time my son was in his presence while drunk).

I am struggling greatly.  I have to stay in Paris working until end of Sept and have found a few meetings. Right now my "sober at the moment" partner and son are with me. He is fine right now, but I KNOW that it will happen again in one, two or three years when he lets his guard down again. I am daunted by the looming fear...When will it be? What will it ruin? What will the effects be on my son when it happens?

My parents and a few friends probably wouldn't speak to me again if they knew he was here and I was allowing to be with my son.

I am literally sick about it. This was my dream job summer and it has turned into an emotional nightmare that I can't wake up from.

I am wondering if other people with kids have faced similar dilemmas.

Camille



__________________


~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 3613
Date:

I am so glad you have found us, and so sorry you are going through this. I wanted to say that I have had very similar experiences.  My AH (alcoholic husband) was a binge drinker, so he could go for a long time with no drinking, when I thought he was done with it for good, and then suddenly he'd start again and everything would go out of control. He was taking care of our son, who was three, while I had to work abroad -- 8000 miles away -- for three weeks. He had been sober for quite a while but of course that was the time that the binge started again. You can imagine the rest.

One thing that I eventually realized, in my own case, was that he wasn't going to stop.  He could be sober for long periods but the relapsing wasn't going to stop. In our case, he put our son in physical danger one time. We were staying in a high-rise building and I came home one day to find my AH passed out and our three-year-old with nobody watching and a window that reached down nearly to the floor wide open.  It was a miracle that our son didn't just climb or fall out that window. When my AH was sober, we had actually discussed the necessity of always keeping that window closed and locked.  (Why a high building had a dangerous window like that is anybody's guess, but there will always be something dangerous.)  That's when I decided to leave my AH.  But everyone's situation is different.

My AH and our son are close, and what I realized is that I just must treat AH as if he is always going to drink, because I can't predict when he is.  So when they go out to lunch together, they walk, not drive. I don't let my AH pick our son up from school because that requires a car.  Etc.  The good thing is that your child, like ours, will soon be older, and as he gets older he has more autonomy.  I know that if our AH passed out again with my son there, my son could phone me and I could come and get him.  I should say that also as our son has gotten older, I believe my AH has been more careful about visible drinking, so that he has never passed out or anything in front of our son again.  If he had, I would revise my plans of what they can do.

This also means that when I'm gone I get other people to watch our son.  I've developed a wide network of parents of his friends and other people he trusts, and when I have to go to a business meeting or something over a weekend, he goes over to one of them, not with his dad. I'm not sure he even realizes he's being "babysat"; I think he thinks it's a fun sleepover with a friend.  Of course we have lots of his friends over too so it's balanced and not one-sided.  But this means that I'm not thrown on having to depend on my AH (now ex-AH) for care.

That was the solution we arrived at.  If I could do one thing differently, I would have gone into my own recovery at Al-Anon earlier.  I hope you can do that, find meetings, get a sponsor, and learn all you can.  Keep coming back.



__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

Whoa....I am pretty floored by some of the eerily similar details of our respective circumstances. Thank you SO much for your response. I have amazing parents and friends who care a lot, but a few of them tend to respond so strongly and judgmentally, it can feel a bit like an attack, rather than support...which does not help so much when you are just trying to navigate out of an emotionally traumatic situation.

The wide open window is a beyond-horrific thought. My partner has now put my son in danger a few times, first when he was a 6-week-old infant when he relapsed the first time after 3 years of sobriety and dropped him on the corner of the changing table. (I only found out he had relapsed when the ER nurse announced he had been drinking.)

And, during this most recent episode, when he tried to take my son back from my friend's house and get him into a car that he had parked on the wrong side of the street, on the sidewalk (to indicate what kind of shape he was in.) Both a physical risk and traumatizing to my son.

The words you have chosen are the same words I have been using for the past two weeks. I have been saying that I now have to make preparations as if he will drink again, because it will happen and it is impossible to predict when.

I am so impressed that you were able to make the decision you did, act on it, and stick to it.

My mistake was to let my trust build up and allow my son stay with him while I was gone.

Here in Paris, I bought my son a cell phone and he knows exactly how to dial my number (proven by him calling me about every 10 minutes.) So we are in constant contact and I see them every few hours.

I am in a childcare predicament right now because I am working full time in a city where my son knows nobody or the language, (and I am now virtually fund-less in terms of hiring a nanny or funding daycamps).

I "believe" he won't relapse here because he is so freshly remorseful and appalled by his own behavior. (And my son will tell me if daddy buys a glass or bottle of wine.) But I still have a pit in my stomach, because despite the safeguards, it seems that just based on principle, I shouldn't be letting him take care of him AT ALL. (And like I said, my parents and one friend in particular would probably disown me if they knew.)

But I am thinking VERY carefully about what to do when I get back to the states Sept 28th. I supported this man as a "stay-at-home dad who freelances" for many years, so to ask him to leave means either paying for another place for him (did that for a year and a half) or just letting him go homeless, which I can't do. Despite his horrific disease and relapses I do care for him like family and he is, WHEN SOBER, a gentle, caring soul and productive, reliable, fun, funny father. That's why it is so hard. I do not have the urge to punish and hurt him. I just want everything to be as okay for everyone as it can be under these awful, heart-breaking circumstances.

If you don't mind me asking, did you and your AH get lawyers involved to develop a parenting plan that you felt comfortable with? Or did you and your AH just make an agreement between the two of you? I foresee a lot of resistance on my partner's part. But he does know that if it ever went to court there is vast documentation to show that he has a massive, detrimental alcohol problems.

I have told my partner that I am still trying to decide how to move forward and that my decision to allow him to help out in Paris is based on desperation and does not mean that things are moving forward for us as a couple business as usual. (But I don't think he hears it.) It will be very difficult to tell him that he has to move out again, because he sees himself as sober and committed to sobriety. 

I think I will try to work this out with a counselor in the room. He will not understand why he can't do things like pick Oliver up from school, etc., when he has been doing so successfully for the past 15 months and only had (as he puts it) a "one-day" slip up.

Uggh.

Sorry that this is soooo long. Obviously a lot I am trying to think through!

Thank you again.

Camille



__________________


~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 3613
Date:

Oh boy, that is terrifying about the car.  The fact that your husband is minimizing it ("It was only a one-day slip-up!") is terrifying as well.  It suggests to me that he still doesn't understand what tragedy could have happened if he had tried to drive your son in that condition.  If I ever found that I had made a decision like that, I would check myself into rehab the next day or even quicker.  The fact that he just takes this in stride shows just how insane this disease makes people.

I think when we first begin to realize how severe the problem is, it takes a little while to get everything set up so that we can detach our life from the alcoholic's.  During that time we just pray that things work out safely. However, when we're thrown on our own resources, it's my experience that it's amazing what we can do.  I never would have predicted that I could be the single mother of a three-year-old in a demanding career and come out of it sane with most things taken care of pretty well.  And yet it has worked out.  Our son is ten now.

My AH was also the stay-at-home parent because he was self-employed with a part-time and not very lucrative career.  It was not very lucrative partly because of the choice of career and partly because his work habits were not the steadiest.  At his most successful he hardly made enough to support a single person.  I thought that once I asked him to leave, he'd have to ask his parents (who weren't very well off themselves) for money to support him.  He had never shown any ability to support himself with any security. But come to find out that he has kept himself going just fine all these years.  When you throw alcoholics onto their own resources, they're more able than they can appear.  I now think he projected a sense of helplessness and incapability all those years to keep from having to be an equal contributor.  I thought he would be living under a bridge within six months.  He's pleaded that he's too poor to contribute child support.  But I sell things on eBay now and again and I look at his sales record.  Come to find out that he's spending hundreds of dollars buying frivolities (such as comic books) on eBay.  I never would have known, just as I never would have known the extent of his drinking.  These days I don't really believe he's helpless any more than I believe he's longterm sober.

In our case I was lucky because he just went along with what I decided about custody and access.  He's not very combative, plus he knew that I would arm myself to the teeth with lawyers and evidence if he tried to oppose the plan.  I have tried not to be blaming.  I say, "I don't know whether you're drinking or not, and I'm not asking you to tell me.  But I have to make sure [our son] is safe, and so I'm going to assume that you might be drinking, and so I can't let him do [whatever] with you."  He just rolls his eyes as if I'm this crazy person who still has this deranged idea that he drinks.  (Even when the court ordered that he go into rehab, he blamed it on a judge who has the same deranged idea that he drinks.)  He'll never believe there's anything to this.  But he knows the law will be on my side, and he can't afford a sharp lawyer to combat it.  And truth be told, I think he likes having even less responsibility than he did before.  So he gets to live his own drunken life without anyone to stop him, plus see his son sometimes.  That's his idea of a good life.  And as long as I can keep our son safe, I think that's a comparatively happy way for this whole mess to end.  He does mean well.  But he's in the grip of a disease and that's the way it is.

Sorry this has been so long.  Hope my experience helps.  Take what you like and leave the rest.



-- Edited by Mattie on Monday 25th of July 2011 03:12:00 PM

__________________


~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 3870
Date:

I'm cross talking and it's an oops .. Mattie I really like what you had to say about his drinking,

"I don't know whether you're drinking or not, and I'm not asking you to tell me. But I have to make sure [our son] is safe, and so I'm going to assume that you might be drinking, and so I can't let him do [whatever] with you."

That is such a great quote, this is what is so scary about the whole dry drunk thing is the unknown. Thank you for this because it's just something I needed to reflect upon.

P :)

__________________

Stepping onto a brand-new path is difficult, but not more difficult than remaining in a situation, which is not nurturing to the whole woman.- Maya Angelo



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

Thank you so much for sharing your story. You are so right! The incident was more than terrifying. I heard the whole thing transpire over the phone from across the Atlantic and wanted to fly through space and swoop up my son. I have never in my life felt so helpless or panicked. I don't care if it was one day or one minute. It was horrific. Period.

I, too, did the single parent thing with my very demanding (long and unpredictable hours with lots of travel for production) job. My alcoholic partner (AP?) (ABF?) went through six months of rehabs/relapses/ER visits/detox/disappearing (seriously, missing person for 5 days) a couple of years ago before I finally forced him into an apartment and went on with life. My son was four. I wish I could say it was easy, but I actually thought it was very stressful and very expensive. Maybe it would be easier if my job didn't require me to travel weeks at a time. But it does, so I had to bring my nanny and pay for all of her expenses. And now that my son is in school, I would have to hire someone I trust and who he is happy with to watch him. So, for me, my current job probably isn't sustainable as a single parent. (I think that's why after a year and a half of sobriety, I let him eek his way back into the family.)

My ABF definitely wants to be involved on a day-to-day level with my son and has been (besides the 6-month period of relapse indicated above) his primary caretaker during the day. He has been very good at it too, teaching my son golf (he was accepted into the world championships this year), soccer and participating as the class photographer at his school. Cooks, cleans, does my errands. That's why it's so hard for me to write him off. But it is also so hard for me NOT to write him off.

I should also add that my ABF is a lot older than I am, and I am 42! He was in the corporate world in my industry, and it's a young industry, so he is not very employable at this point...plus his health has deteriorated so he definitely can't do physical stuff. He has helped me renovate two old houses, which increased my net worth a bit. So, as ridiculous as it sounds, I actually do feel like I have give him some money to live. Maybe I sell my nice house and give him some money. Uggh.

I don't feel protective of my ABF at this point, but I do feel protective of my son and what my son gets from him during the long periods (years) when he is sober. A lot to figure out!

Thank you for bearing with me. Hearing what you have to say is very meaningful.

Merci beaucoup, as my new French friends say!

Camille



__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

I totally agree. I am gripped by fear of the unknown, and that is something that I need my ABF to respect.

It is not fear of what is happening right now before my eyes (his sobriety), it is what has happened in the past and what I fear will happen in the future.

Until there is some kind of machine that can give me a guarantee, I will live with a pit in my stomach.



__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:

As the adult child of an alcoholic, I have an entirely different perspective. Some of what I have to say may be tough for others to swallow, but life can be pretty ugly sometimes.

I was physically and sexually abused by an alcoholic, who also did other things that often put myself and my younger brother in danger. J (I dont want to use her name, but I refuse to call her mom anymore) didnt do anything to stop it. She even caught him in my room once, but denied the abuse till the day she died. She always said that she made a vow before God and she wasnt going to break it just because things got tough. If that was her choice, thats her business, but I never felt she had the right to make that choice for us. If she wanted to stay, more power to her, but she should have made other arrangements for us, for the sake of our safety. To this day, I have FAR more anger toward her than I do toward him. At least he had the excuse that he was drunk and didnt know what he was doing. She had no such excuse. She could have done something and she chose not to. As far as Im concerned, shes as guilty of abuse as he was, if not more so.

Dont think that anyone (especially the alcoholic, but not even the kids either) will ever appreciate your willingness to let the kids spend time with dad so they can get to know him. Too often, we do what we think is best, when really all it is is whats easy. Too many people make the mistake of trying so hard not to step on the alcoholics rights and feeling sooooooo sorry for the poor, poor alcoholic who just cant help himself. Well, maybe he cant, but if YOU can do something to protect the kids from him, DO IT, and the hell with his rights! It only takes one instance of letting your guard down for a kid to be scarred for life, whether mentally, emotionally, physically or sexually. Not only do you have to live with that for the rest of your life, but so does your kid. I would have given ANYTHING for somebody anybody! to be more concerned about MY right not to be abused than about HIS right to do the things he did things that he never remembered afterwards, but that Ill never be able to forget. Hes been dead over 30 years, and I still read the recovery books, go to meetings and come to online groups like this one.

Living on your guard 24/7 is a hell of a way to live - the stress alone will kill you after a while. Kids dont always understand why parents make the decisions we make, and some kids might scream and cry and accuse you of all sorts of hateful things because you wont let them see the other parent anymore. Their safety is FAR more important than their understanding. Being a parent sometimes means making unpopular decisions (whether keeping the alcoholic away from the kids or even finding yourself another job so you don't "have" to rely on him as much as you obviously think you have to). BE THE PARENT! It may be tough for a while, but trust me, someday they will understandand theyll thank you for it.

Red Hawk



__________________

My heart is moved by all I cannot save: so much has been destroyed.
I have to cast my lot with those who, age after age, perversely,
with no extraordinary power, reconstitute the world.
A passion to make, and make again, where such un-making reigns.



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

Thank you VERY much for sharing your perspective and your story Red Hawk. I am sickened by what you've gone through. And I am so, so sorry that no one protected you. There are no recovery books that can right that wrong. I wish there were something that could. To be abused by the people who are supposed to protect you.

When my ABF relapsed the first time after years of sobriety and spiraled out of control, I removed him from my house. I made it clear that any kind of relationship with our son would be contingent upon his sobriety. (Which it has been.) I would NEVER sit by idly and watch my son be abused by anyone. I hope that is crystal clear.

I have never knowingly put my son in the presence of his father when he was drinking or when I thought there was even a slight chance he would drink. BUT, and this is a big BUT, what I am realizing is that no matter how many years pass by with him being sober, there will always be a chance he could start again. A very strong chance that he will again. And this is why I am here and why I appreciate everyone's perspective SO much.

I will do anything to protect my child from harm (physical and emotional), including selling my house, quitting my job and moving. That's not to say those things won't be very, very difficult for my son and me. Figuring out the right thing to do and doing it, hard or easy, is not a snap...like I said before, it would be cut and dried if things hadn't stabilized immediately. I guess I should be grateful because I actually have a moment to think things through and to prepare for the future.

I am just gonna say it. This really sucks!



__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 39
Date:

One of the most tragic things about alcoholism is that, because it's a disease, relapse can happen at any time and without any warning. I've heard of people being sober for years on end and then suddenly they start drinking again. It seems to happen less with people who are either in therapy or AA because they have a support network they can fall back on and they're working on the issues that cause them to drink in the first place, but it still happens. It seems to happen more, though, with people like your guy who are only doing it to get what they want. It sounds like he's only trying to stay sober to appease you so he can see his son, not because he believes he really has a problem and needs to change. Judging by his flippant remark that he just had a one-day slip, he still doesn't realize he's an alcoholic.

I'm glad you found Al-Anon and these message boards here at MIP. Have you ever considered looking into Codependents Anonymous (CoDA), as well? You might find that helpful, too. Melody Beattie has written some excellent books on the subject that I highly recommend.

I have several daily readers that I use regularly, and this is part of one of my very favorite readings. It comes from a book for ACoAs, but I hope you find it helpful: "Today I will be gentle with myself...I will experience this day without demanding perfection from myself or others...To promote my recovery, I live each moment treating myself with gentleness and kindness...I feel renewed and encouraged as I concentrate less on finding the correct answers to my problems and more on how I am treating myself along the way. As I learn to take care of myself, answers will come." (June 16)

Today's reading also seems appropriate:

I Will Not Control My Loved Ones

I will cherish my own individuality today, and I will respect the individuality of others. I will not control my loved ones, nor will I take responsibility for their actions or their words. Many times in the past, I've tried to control the alcoholic's behavior by continually making excuses for their embarrassing behavior, their blunders, their excesses and their diminished responsibility. Instead of feeling my own individuality, I felt responsible for the alcoholic's actions.

I will be strong today and concentrate on maintaining my own personhood. I will not take responsibility for anyone else's actions or emotions.

I will be able to detach emotionally from the stresses of others. I will accept my powerlessness over others. I will accept myself, and I will accept others in their own unique individuality.

I will cherish my individuality today. (July 27)

Rokelle Lerner, Daily Affirmations for Adult Children of Alcoholics

Believe me, I know it sucks! No matter what you decide to do, there are no easy answers, and I certainly don't envy you the choices you're facing. Just dig in deep to your Higher Power for the strength and wisdom you need. And keep coming back! smile

Red Hawk



__________________

My heart is moved by all I cannot save: so much has been destroyed.
I have to cast my lot with those who, age after age, perversely,
with no extraordinary power, reconstitute the world.
A passion to make, and make again, where such un-making reigns.



~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 662
Date:

I want to suggest you read the book "Getting Them Sober" by Toby Rice Drews, I think it will help you answer some questions. I hope you are attending meetings and find a sponsor soon. I am sending you love and support.

__________________

 

God grant me the serenity 
To accept the things I cannot change,
Courage to change the things I can,
And wisdom to know the difference. 

Al-Anon/Alateen Family Group Headquarters, Inc. 800-344-2666



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

Well, Mattie, I reached the same point you reached after your husband put your son in danger...I have finally officially left my partner.

It is very clear that his sobriety after another traumatizing incident for my son, that my partner's sobriety will always be intermittent. My son and I had to urgently move cities (I took a new job--a great one, at least). Now my ex-partner is packing up his stuff in the old house in the old city and will hopefully leave when it gets rented. (Of course, he has said that he won't leave even though I own the house.) Add all the drama to the fact that I have had to find housing, get my son into school AND knock it out of the park in a new job (and my dog died a few weeks ago) and it has been VERY stressful.

I know I have no alternative but to keep my son away from him right now as he is too unpredictable. Don't know whether in the future, IF he is sober, if I will let him see my son in a controlled environment or if that would be too confusing or hurtful to my son when his dad falls off the wagon again.

I think what floors me is that though I'm doing the right thing I am in so much pain (for my son) for the loss of our family and with the worry of my ex-partner's welfare. (Probably doesn't help that we have left ALL of the life we had, not just dad, a great neighborhood and school!) Trying to be positive and believe that there is a light at the end of the tunnel, but there is a lot of anxiety attached with moving on!!!!!!!!!! At moments, I feel a little bit free, but mostly, as a mom of a a now virtually fatherless son, I just feel like a wreck right now. Did anyone ever feel this way?



__________________


~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 3870
Date:

Camille,

Hugs and I'm soooo glad to see you back with an update! You will need to talk to someone that is a professional however it is my understanding if there is anything legal in the works as a DUI or anything that is documented you can ask the courts to require him to wear a SCRAM bracelet. My AH wears one of those currently and it tracks alcohol in the system through vapors. There is a catch it can be expensive first off however it's something that if my AH and I split up I know in our state that it is something I could ask the courts for because he had a DUI within the past year. I don't know what the time limit is, I do know that currently I could ask for an extension.

Mattie, had some really great ESH on this issue.

I'm so sorry you are in pain at the moment and I'm going to suggest even though you are no longer with your A that attending face to face alanon meetings is a great place to start in dealing with the loss of a relationship especially when it is addiction motivated. Something I can tell you that if there were a group of 100 eligible guys and 2 were addicts I would find the 2 that were addicts. It's just how I am wired and I know regardless of what happens with my AH and myself that I will need alanon to help me deprogram my thinking. I know no matter what I do not want to choose unconsciously or consciously another addict. I want to make healthy choices because I am of healthy mind, body and spirit.

Hugs again and welcome back,

P :)

__________________

Stepping onto a brand-new path is difficult, but not more difficult than remaining in a situation, which is not nurturing to the whole woman.- Maya Angelo



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:

Thank you Pushka. I am so worried about my son. He has hardly said anything about his dad. He talks about missing his dog. I worry he is holding it inside. Did you encourage your children to talk about it?

__________________


~*Service Worker*~

Status: Offline
Posts: 3870
Date:

Camille Le Montre wrote:

I worry he is holding it inside. Did you encourage your children to talk about it?


My kids have had alcoholics in their life since they were born, my AH's parents and sdad are all alcoholics (sdad has since passed away).  So I really try and have open honest conversations and let them know no matter what, even if they can't talk to their dad or myself that we will always find them the support they need so they can find their voice in any given situation.  Talk about alcoholism has always been open and on going. 

Sometimes it's just hard to talk to parents about this stuff and being it's their Dad this time around I just want them to feel secure that we can and will talk about this, sorry dad .. lol ..  we are not going to shush them if they talk about things.  I always try to be sure to be fair, I'm very aware of that, this is their dad at the same time he's human JUST like me.  We fall down and get back up. 

What I'm soooo grateful for with my kids is they are so vocal about things.  They are both pretty comfortable with stating how they feel in situations and do a good job of naming the emotion. 

I allow them to take the lead unless I can see they are having a hard time with something. 

Hugs P :)



__________________

Stepping onto a brand-new path is difficult, but not more difficult than remaining in a situation, which is not nurturing to the whole woman.- Maya Angelo

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.