The material presented
here is not Al-Anon Conference Approved Literature. It is a method
to exchange
information, ideas, feelings, problems and solutions on a personal
level.
You have always been so helpful to me, so I thought I would seek your ESH on separating from my AH in regards to our children. My AH (finally!!) moved out on December 30 (this is a very, very good thing for me). Kids took the news well, asked questions, and I am working to keep a very open dialogue on this with them. This weekend is the first weekend the kids (ages 11, 9, and 6) are with AH. I asked him not to drink while he had them, but he said that that was ridiculous. He invited me to go to dinner with all of them, then uninvited me after an argument last night, then invited me again. I went because I had told the kids that I would see them tonight and I did not want to disappoint them or let them down...plus, I just miss them so much!
Dinner was a disaster. He ordered beer and for the first time since before he went through treatment this summer was openly drinking in front of our kids. All 3 were visibly shocked and my youngest whispered in my ear, "Isn't Dad not supposed to be drinking?" Then in the middle of dinner he started to become tearful, left to go to the car, returned, and then left again for good, asking me to bring the kids to his apartment after dinner. When I got there, he clearly had been drinking more heavily and was argumentative. Later this evening, my youngest called me and said he was angry with her because she wanted to call and say goodnight.
My concerns:
1. Obvious: having my kids at his apartment when he is drinking/drunk. This will be an ongoing thing because he sees nothing wrong with it. He does not believe he is alcoholic, despite his 5 days in detox and his 30 day IOP. Do I take legal action? How have you all handled this? Am I giving a mixed message to them and to him by allowing them to stay there every other weekend? (the weekday visits are at our house and are just while I am working until 9:00 pm then he leaves).
2. How to handle when he is nasty to them (like when my daughter wanted to call me) because he is angry with me.
3. Ways to talk to my kids about his drinking.
4. Dealing with kids who are torn between 2 houses and 2 parents, who are confused, sad, wondering.
Any comments, ESH, or even advice would be more than welcome.
Your kids are old enough to read some literature with you on this disease the alateen book A day at a time ADAT is awsome a friend used to read the paragraph for the day let her kids talk about what they thought it meant and she would explain her thoughts on the page . Alcoholics do what alcoholics do ---- drink , Asking him not to drink when he has the kids in theory should work but as u have already seen it dosent . Your kids are old enough to know when he has been drinking too much and if they become frightened they could phone u and u can go and pick them up .Just a thought and if he continues i would ask for supervised visits thru family services , our kids need to feel safe and count on us to be there for them .
This is a difficult situation, and I know you are caught between a rock and a hard place with this, so I am just give MY opinion and hope you will not be offended by same. I would have difficulties leaving children this young with someone with alcoholism. With the best will in the world I do not believe he can stay sober, though he may have the best of intentions. It may be that you might need to supervise these visits yourself or with someone else. Also as a child of an alcoholic, its damaging to the children to witness this by themselves, not so much with you as a stable responsible parent. I do not want to fill your head with needless fears, but as a double winner here, I know my own behaviour was not exemplary as a mother while under the influence of alcohol, so I coming from that place, rather than one of non-understanding.
Dear Maire--thank you for your thoughts. I completely agree, and the thought of having my kids with my AH in a visitation-type situation has been so terrifying for me that that has literally kept me in the relationship for longer than what I should have stayed. He is in complete denial (at least to me) that there is any problem at all with his drinking. When I spoke to an attorney about this very thing, he was not optimistic about being able to legislate that he cannot drink while they are with him, plus it is impossible to enforce. I appreciate your thoughts on this and they certainly echo mine. Thank you.
Maybe your attorney can tell you what the options are for some kind of supervised visitation. There are agencies that provide space for that, or you may be able to arrange something on your own -- maybe the kids meet him in a public place (a pizza restaurant, an ice rink, etc.) A shorter visitation, as these would be, will also minimize problems.
I agree that he won't not drink. Drinking is what they do. So: what kind of visitation would be manageable with him drinking? It might be just once or twice a month for a couple of hours.
Your attorney can also advise you if you need to get the custody arrangements changed in court. If you have physical evidence of his drinkings (DUIs, etc.), that would help. But if he's agreeable to changing the arrangements informally, you can just do it that way.
Aloha 3lks I've worked the system before included family services and child welfare including the YWCA programs. In unity they are all focused on child welfare including never putting children in harms way. If family court is involved in your separation I would address the situation with them. I don't ever remember a family court judge approving or making the recommendation of a drinker having custody of any type while actively and if the drinker did drink during the process they would be held in contempt and given consequences. You're alcoholic knows the issues and the reality and when I use to work with guys like that I would accuse them of being in contempt of the reality and being abusive. Just from my experiences.
Under the influence means under the influence of abnormal, irrational and alcohol. Exercising courage in the face of the alcoholic is scary. Practice makes it better.
My three kids are 10-1/2, 9 in 15 days, and just turned 7 last week. When I filed for divorce, full custody was the only option I would consider. My AH was so deep in his disease at that point, though, that there he couldn't take care of himself, let alone the kids. But as he was a homeless alcoholic with four DUI's, I felt pretty safe with me getting full custody.
Right now he's living nearby, renting a room and sober for maybe 12 weeks now (I don't try to keep track anymore). He doesn't have a license, so no car. I decide when the kids get to see him. If he had the type of visitation you described, I'd be sick with worry.
As long as he's sober, I figure out how to make that work at least a couple times a week - but NEVER overnight. They spend a lot of time at the library and just for the last 4-6 weeks, I've been letting them visit where he lives, since he's got his own room and a TV in it. If he's drinking, he doesn't even want the kids around, so that hasn't been an issue.
My older two have both read "What's Drunk, Mama" and we all three are in counseling. It definitely helped us to start talking.
While I spend more time around the ex than I'd like to at this point, as long as he's sober, it's good for the kids to see him. He's still their Daddy and they love him. I just try to explain that Daddy's loves them, but he's sick.
Keep protecting your little ones - they're counting on you to take care of them.
Just wanted to chime in as a mom who has recently separated from her alcoholic husband. Right after I left, all visitations took place with ME supervising. That really ticked my STBX off. We went to mediation as required by law, and I informed STBX and the mediator that I was concerned for my daughter's safety while in the presence of her father, due to his drinking (among other thing). STBX volunteered not to drink in her presence. I ended up demanding that he not drink in the 12 hours preceeding the visitation, to ensure that no trace of alcohol was left in his system. Surprisingly, he agreed, perhaps because he was tired of me supervising him. My lawyer later told me that the most I could obtain from the court was an order for STBX not to drink while caring for our child, OR, if he showed up drunk, I could deny him visitation. I would have to make sure to log all instances of his intoxication and present this to my lawyer, so a new custody agreement could be ratified.
All this say, check with a lawyer for the applicable laws in your area. Are you planning on trying to get custody of your children? I'd say you stand a good chance if your X has DUIs and been in treatment...You might even be able to get court ordered supervised visitation only...
And, it might be helpful to journal and write down every instance of intoxication (with dates and times and summaries of events).
I second the Al-Ateen thing. I introduced my stepson to the Al-Anon chat room meetings and he later told me he got a lot out of it.